Best Sensitive Mascara (2025)

FAQs

What is the safest mascara for sensitive eyes? ›

CoverGirl Professional All-in-One Mascara

A Good Housekeeping Seal star and cult classic, CoverGirl's formulation, which comes in a waterproof version, is made specifically for sensitive eyes and is hypoallergenic as well as suitable for contact lens wearers.

DIME Beauty Volume Mascara is the hypoallergenic mascara I've been searching for. It's a perfect, daily-use, hypoallergenic mascara and a great mascara for allergies and sensitive skin. With a tapered brush, it goes on smooth without smearing or clumping, and it's buildable.

First, choose hypoallergenic mascara, formulated for sensitive eyes. Always do a patch test before applying a new product fully - dab a small amount behind your ear and wait 24 hours. Avoid waterproof mascaras as they contain harsh chemicals that could provoke an allergy.

Avoid mascaras with harsh chemicals

Some mascaras contain harsh chemicals that can irritate sensitive eyes. Avoid mascaras with ingredients like parabens, sulfates, and phthalates. Instead, look for mascaras that are labeled "natural," "organic," or "for sensitive eyes."

Some common preservatives in mascara that can lead to irritation include: parabens. sodium benzoate. quaternium-15 (formaldehyde releaser)

Tubing mascaras have a polymer-based technology that builds flexible tubes around the lashes. These tubes are fairly oil and water-resistant in day-to-day life, but they dissolve with warm water and a bit of gentle rubbing. The level of rubbing needed is low, so you won't need to worry about losing lashes.

Clinique High Impact High-Fi Full Volume Mascara

It's ophthalmologist-tested, allergy-tested, free of fragrance, and safe for sensitive eyes, which are just a few reasons why our testers scored this best mascara at Ulta with high marks across the board.

L'Oréal Voluminous Lash Mascara

The original version of this L'Oréal mascara has been a longtime fan-favorite for its super volumizing formula, and we like the waterproof one just as much. The big wand has more than 200 bristles that separate the lashes and provide buildable volume.

What mascara does Jennifer Aniston use? ›

Melanie Simon, Jennifer Aniston's facialist, revealed a few months ago the that Ilia Limitless Lash mascara was one of her top beauty product picks, according to her interview with Who What Wear. "This is my absolute favorite mascara for lengthening," she said about the best-selling formula.

If your eyes burn whenever you wear mascara — either right away or after a few hours — it's likely because of ingredients in the mascara's formula that you're allergic or sensitive to.

To get rid of an eye makeup allergy, stop using the offending product immediately. Cleanse the area gently with a hypoallergenic cleanser. Avoid using any makeup until symptoms subside. In future, opt for hypoallergenic makeup brands to minimize the risk of allergic reactions.

If you suffer from allergies or are super sensitive to eye makeup, you may be looking for a hypoallergenic mascara option. Whether you are looking for an allergy-friendly lengthening, volumizing, or even waterproof mascara, Sephora's got you covered.

The burning, itching or swelling of the eyes and/or eyelids related to mascara use is caused by a condition called contact dermatitis. Symptoms of contact dermatitis can develop when certain substances — irritants or allergens — come into contact with the skin. Irritants are the more common cause of dermatitis.

Advantages of Tubing Mascara Over Regular Mascara

Easy and Safe Removal: Unlike traditional mascaras, which may require special removers, tubing mascara slides off easily with warm water, reducing the risk of irritation and making it ideal for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers.